A Tale of Two Cities

Deborah Clark • Apr 06, 2021

"There is a tide in the affairs of men. Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune." Which Baring brother are you?

Let me take you from the world of international finance down an historical rabbit hole back to the heart of pre-industrial Devon. Scene 1: it’s 26th February 1995 and trader Nick Leeson, based out of Singapore, has just toppled the oldest merchant bank in the UK. We gasped at the lack of scrutiny by the bank, the chutzpah without charm of the rogue trader. Leeson was trading in futures with no grasp on tomorrow.


Flashback: it’s 1717 and 20 year-old Johann Baring arrives in Exeter from his hometown of Bremen. George I is on the throne and you know the gregarious, social climbing, grasping Georgians are some of my favourite people. Johann is taking an apprenticeship in wool trading and this was big in Devon at the beginning of the 18th century. I could go on about the loveliness of wool and its importance in the economy of Devon: production involved the whole family – from farming, shearing, carding to spinning and weaving, everyone had a role. And each family’s small-scale production fed into the markets of the county and from there to Exeter, for export around the country and the world.


Step into the story 25 year-old Elizabeth Vowler, only child and heiress of John Vowler, a rich “grocer”, importing tea and sugar. Elizabeth had a dowry of £20,000, or over £4m today. But don’t dismiss John as a gold digger – by now he’s a British citizen with a British name – he bided his time and he didn’t marry Elizabeth just for her money. Doubtless there was mutual attraction, and all the more strongly because she had been a silent partner in her father’s business. It was a match of equals and Elizabeth was an important commercial player both before and after her husband’s early death, in 1748.


The couple had five children, two of whom, I think, symbolize a turning point in Devon’s history. The oldest, John junior, was 18 when his father died, Francis just 8. Elizabeth continued running the family business, now worth £40,000.


Now it gets interesting, since the Industrial Revolution was just around the corner and very few people in Devon sensed it yet. Young Francis was sent away to London, first at school and then apprenticed to a leading cloth merchant with direct experience of the new mechanical cloth spinning trade. John, just 10 years’ older, missed that opportunity boat. On Christmas Day 1762, Elizabeth lent her sons the seed capital to found a bank. Well, two banks; Francis Baring of London and John Baring of Exeter. The idea was that London would find a market to sell the wool produced in Devon, via the Exeter bank. This was the first merchant bank in the UK and just the second in Europe.


Grasping the opportunities available in London, Francis expanded into financial services and, yes, slaving. In 1774, Barings was doing business in the US, positioning itself before Independence. Think of the turmoil of those times, recently matched by our own. Revolutions, the Napoleonic Wars: a fertile breeding ground for innovation. In 1802 Barings facilitated the purchase by the USA of Louisiana from the French, “one of the most historically significant trades of all time”, for $15,000,000, most of it in US bonds technically sold by Napoleon to Barings and sold on with a profit of 12.5%. It almost doubled the size of the USA and financed Napoleon’s war effort against Britain. The pursuit of money rarely aligns with the national interest.


So what happened to John? This is a domestic story, as his wife of just 8 years died in 1765, leaving him with six children. All of John’s focus returned to Exeter, where he lived (and bought a lot of it) until his death at a good old age, in 1816.


This is what I mean by the brothers representing a turning point: Francis went to London, made a fortune, got a peerage and leapt feet-first into new trades and politics. John chose a quieter life based on what he already knew and what he had learned from his parents. By the end of their lives they were virtually living in different ages, as were their respective home cities. 


The Industrial Revolution didn’t work for Devon; we’re founded on farming, fishing and food. More recently, people have flocked to Devon for pleasure not dark satanic mills. But, like the Baring brothers, we’re living through a combination of global turmoil and new technologies. Has the pull of London waned? Will the ebb draw ambition and talent back to Devon in future?

By deborah 19 Mar, 2023
With another psycho-drama on the horizon this week, today happens to be 3 years to the day since Team SH came out of our mini-cobra meeting, shut the hotel doors and turned off the lights. Over the next 2 years, those lights went on and off, flickered and flared. Who knew that passively reacting could be so exhausting? Was I missing some cunning strategy, a grand plan, a pathway to sanity. Well, as it happens....
A young woman with soulful eyes in 1920s dress regards the viewer with confidence.
By deborah 16 Dec, 2022
The art at SH has been selected either to tell the history of the House through the eyes of its first owner, William Kirkpatrick, or to complement the eclectic and quirky style of the hotel. While its all got to look cool and sexy, our higher aim is to wrap you in a narrative that feels positive, interesting, off-beat and purposeful...
By deborah 19 Jun, 2022
A bite-sized canter through the centuries of trade and colonialism that informed much of the design and personality of Southernhay House. Hang on for the ride:
By Deborah Clark 03 May, 2022
Funky and Fab-u-lous, orange wine is having a moment right now, and SoHoEx is on board.
By Deborah Clark 14 Jul, 2021
Never mind the High Street, hospitality is also getting a long-overdue re-boot on the back of lockdown. I’m going to be brutal about my sector, because the truth is that it was all over the place at the end of 2019.
By Deborah Clark 14 Jun, 2021
What do you see in this picture? Me first: at a simple level I see three beautiful women dancing together in a stylised idyllic setting. The flowers underfoot, the position of the women, their hands clasped and caressing make me think along classical lines - maybe three graces?
By Deborah Clark 08 May, 2021
If you never use booking.com or any other Online Travel Agent (OTA) I give you a virtual high five.
By Deborah Clark 26 Dec, 2020
This is what we did during lockdown. We didn’t plan it this way, of course.
By Deborah Clark 05 Jun, 2020
Remember when you first saw the iPhone screen move? You're really going to need to draw on your childhood sense of wonder to get your social kicks in 2020. In this extraordinary year, the longest-term effects may be on hospitality.
By Deborah 14 May, 2020
The present pandemic is part of a deadly dance that has lasted for centuries. The first one to hit our shores has an eerie similarity to C-19. Can we learn from how that played out?
More Posts
Share by: